Magic: The Gathering

Magic: The Gathering

2133 Products

Magic the Gathering Graded Cards

Whether you’re a passionate Magic the Gathering collector or ready to start collecting trading cards for the very first time, Nostalgium is the place to find the Magic Cards you need to flesh out your collection. 

At Nostalgium, every Magic The Gathering card in our inventory is professionally graded and sealed, giving collectors confidence in authenticity, condition, and long-term value. We specialize exclusively in graded MTG cards, offering rare and investment-worthy pieces that are difficult to find anywhere else.

Why Choose Graded Magic Cards?

Unlike raw, ungraded cards that are commonly used for gameplay, professionally graded MTG cards are preserved in secure slabs and assigned grades based on their condition from some of the most trusted companies in the industry. These protect their condition and ensure that they maintain (or even increase) their value over time.

Magic The Gathering cards continue to have a loyal, global fanbase. That means the market stays consistently strong, giving you plenty of opportunities to buy, hold, and resell cards for a profit. You can also build a one-of-a-kind collection by exploring our ever-changing inventory. 

Our Curated Selection of MTG Cards

Our inventory of cards is always being updated to provide collectors like you with plenty of options. We have cards that are priced for entry-level collectors, as well as high-value alpha and mythic options. If you want to establish yourself as a serious collector, Nostalgium has the inventory to help get you started. 

Secure Your Next Magic Collectible With Nostalgium

Invest in the future of your collection with high-quality, graded Magic cards for sale. Whether you’re after a rare item or a mint-condition piece from an MTG set, Nostalgium offers an unparalleled selection.

Why Shop Nostalgium?

Professional Grading

We use the most respected grading services in the industry such as CGC, PSA, & BGS.

Comprehensive Inspection

All slabs are inspected for damage and cleaned thoroughly before we ship.

Safe Packaging Guarantee

We package our slabs in multiple layers of protection (shells - bubble sleeves - bubble mailers) for safe, damage free shipping.

Same Day Shipping

All orders placed before 12pm PST (M-F) are shipped the same day.

Superior Customer Service

We are here for you and your collection journey. Our team is available to help answer any questions or source that hard to find card.

Subscribe & Save

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive 15% off your first order.

!